Reviews

Best Gutter Guards for All Roof Types – Review & Buyer’s Guide

We all know how powerful water is. It can destroy the most robust construction with enough amount of it, not to mention a regular house. Of course, some of you may assume that there is little harm that occasional rain can cause to your home. However, if there is no proper gutter and drainage system installed, every next storm may add up to that leaking ceiling and over flooded basement, not to mention ruined sidings, windows and foundation just because your gutters are clogged.

Read More (Estimated reading time - 20 sec)

Very often, thoughtful homeowners install the gutter system together with the roof. However, if you haven’t done that – there is no issue to worry about. These days there are many gutter systems available on the market, and there are many skilled professionals that can help you install those. Besides, in the majority of cases, you can do it on your own too. When you are considering a new gutter system or wish to upgrade the current one – a useful gutter guard review is needed. We can provide you with a proper gutter guard guide so that you choose the best item fitted to your needs!

Best Gutter Guards for Every Roof Type (Updated May, 2020)

Product Product Information View on Amazon
Editor’s Choice

Raptor Gutter Guard | Stainless Steel Micro-Mesh

1) Raptor Gutter Guard

  • Best Features:
    – Customizable
    – Incredibly durable
    – Seamless and modern design
  • Gutter Type: All
  • Guard Type: Stainless Steel
    Micro-Mesh
  • Size:
    – 5”
    – 6”
    – 7”
  • Length:
    – 4 ft ×. 12pcs

Check Price

Amerimax Home Products 636025 Lock-In Gutter Guard

2) Amerimax Lock-In Gutter Guard

  • Best Features:
    – American-made
    – Affordable
    – Well-thought design
  • Gutter Type: K-style
  • Guard Type: Steel Mesh
  • Size:
    – 4”
    – 5”
    – 6”
  • Length:
    – 3 ft × 25pcs

Check Price

A-M Aluminum Gutter Guard 5

3) A-M Gutter Guard

  • Best Features:
    – Exceptional quality
    – Fair price
    – User-friendly installation
  • Gutter Type: All
  • Guard Type: Perforated
    Aluminum Screen
  • Size:
    – 5”
  • Length:
    – 23 Feet
    – 50 Feet
    – 100 Feet
    – 200 Feet

Check Price

GutterStuff 4-Inch K Style Foam Gutter Filter Insert

4) GutterStuff Foam Gutter Filter

  • Best Features:
    – UV-light resistant
    – Highly affordable
    – Super simple to install
  • Gutter Type: K-Style
  • Guard Type: Foam
  • Size:
    – 4”
    – 5”
    – 6”
  • Length:
    – 192 Feet
    – 144 Feet
    – 96 Feet
    – 32 Feet

Check Price

GutterBrush Simple Gutter Guard | for Standard 5 Gutters

5) THE GUTTERBRUSH

  • Best Features:
    – UV-Light resistant bristles
    – Extremely light
    – User-friendly installment
  • Gutter Type: K-Style
  • Guard Type: Brush
  • Size:
    – 5
  • Length:
    – 6 ft
    – 15 ft
    – 13 ft
    – 60 ft
    – 120 ft

Check Price

Massca Gutter Guard 3 Inch Expand Aluminum Filter Strainer

6) Massca Downspout Gutter Guard

      • Best Features:
        – Water-proof
        – Simple to install
        – Durable
      • Gutter Type: All
      • Guard Type: Aluminum Filter
      • Size: Ø3”

    4 pcs in a pack

Check Price

iRobot Looj 330 Gutter Cleaning Robot

7) iRobot Looj 330 Gutter Cleaning Robot

  • Best Features:
    – Very compact
    – Simple and practical Clean Mode
    – Ensures safe gutter cleaning
  • Gutter Type: All

Check Price

1. Raptor – Best Gutter Guards for Pine Needles

Raptor Gutter Guard | Stainless Steel Micro-Mesh

Many gutter guard types are designed to keep the leaves and other kinds of debris out. However, at times, there are such small things as pine needles that can clog your gutter, and if the guard you use is not designed to filter those out, the chances are that you are going to be trying to unclog the gutters every few months. If you are willing to know if there is a brand that we would advise you to give a try to, that would be Raptor Micro-mesh gutter guards made of stainless steel. Given, guards are made to filter the smallest particles so that only the water gets in. The only thing that you may need to clean is the surface of the guards, that is about it.

Installation details

It is possible to install Raptor guards on your own. However, it requires a set of tools and to succeed with the process. The manufacturer included a precise installation guide with the purchase, so if you follow all the steps carefully, you will end up with well-installed gutter guards in no time. If you want to have a closer look at the process of installation, all you need is in the video below:

Expert Rating
Sturdiness
4.6 / 5
Easy to Install
4.7 / 5
Value for Money
4.8 / 5
Result
4.7
Pros and Cons
The guards are made of highly durable material
You can fix Raptor guards in your gutters with ease
Attractive design will add up to your exterior
Guards can be customized when necessary
Maybe a little challenging to install without proper tools
The price is higher than the average

Best Features

  • Guards designed to filter the tiniest debris, pest, and other small clogging particles
  • Made of non-rust material
  • 25-year item warranty
  • Can be installed under the shingle
Expert Recommendations
Joseph Kirby
Joseph Kirby
Ask Question

"If you live in an area surrounded by pine forests and it rains a lot there, then durable and practical gutter guards are a must. Raptor gutter guards are designed to filter out any small particles so that your gutter system does not get clogged every so often. It is enough to brush away all the debris once or twice a year and spend your free time on something more pleasant than roof or ceiling reparation!"

View On Amazon

2. Amerimax – Easy Installation

Amerimax Home Products 636025 Lock-In Gutter Guard

This is that time when the name speaks for itself. If you are looking for durable gutter guards that are produced by your home country – Amerimax is the manufacturer that you need. What makes these guards different from all the others is the particular pattern that the guards come with and the extremely simple installation process.

The manufacturer ensured that the guards are compatible with such K-style gutter systems as 4, 5, and 6″. The design of the guards is also well-thought of since the precise overlapping ensures that there are no gaps between each guard.

Installation details

As it has been mentioned, the installation is super easy when compared to other brands. All you need to do is to slide the flat side under the roof shingle and then lock the portion that is curved into the front of your gutter system. You can watch the whole process if you follow the video below:

Expert Rating
Sturdiness
4.8 / 5
Value for Money
4.7 / 5
Easy to Install
4.6 / 5
Result
4.7
Pros and Cons
The guards come with 10-years warranty
The sleek design will add up to any exterior
The practical pattern keeps the debris out and allows the water in
The price is more than fair
Lets pine needles and other tiny particles in

Best Features

  • Amerimax gutter guards are made of powder-coated steel which makes them extra-durable
  • Unlike other gutters come in two colors
  • The designed pattern keeps the debris out and ensures that the water gets in easily
Expert Recommendations
Joseph Kirby
Joseph Kirby
Ask Question

"If you are a true patriot of the country and you are interested in good quality for a reasonable price than Amerimax gutter guards are the ones to consider. Besides, if you choose this particular manufacturer, the chances are that you will be able to install them on your own since the installation is claimed to be more than manageable."

View On Amazon

3. A-M Gutter Guard – Best Gutter Screens

A-M Aluminum Gutter Guard 5

Some house owners do not like it when the gutter guards are noticeable, that is when gutter screens come in more than handy. If you are searching for the best-rated gutter screens, then it is safe that A-M if the best-trusted manufacturer on the market.

Even though the guards are designed for hidden hangars, you can use them with other hangars too. Besides, these gutter guard suit both metal and shingle roofs. The material that the guards are made of is aluminum, which means that they are going o last you a lifetime because no rust can take them.

Installation details

This type of gutter guards is also quite simple to install if you follow the manufacturer’s recommendation. The only downside is that you should purchase zip screws on your own since they do not come included in the package. If you are interested in the installation process then we advise you to follow the video below:

Expert Rating
Sturdiness
4.8 / 5
Value for Money
4.7 / 5
Easy to Install
4.6 / 5
Result
4.7
Pros and Cons
The number of holes (380) per foot ensures proper water absorption
Installation is surprisingly easy
The price equals the exceptional quality of the gutter guards
Produced in America
Zip screws needed for installation should be bought separately

Best Features

  • It works on all types of hangars even though it is specially designed for the hidden one
  • Heavy-gauge aluminum ensures extraordinary durability
  • The guards are designed in such a way that they hide within the gutter and remain invisible
Expert Recommendations
Joseph Kirby
Joseph Kirby
Ask Question

"If you are worried that the gutter guards will impact your house exterior, then you need such guards that are invisible. That is precisely what A-M offers. The gutter screen fit the gutters seamlessly and carry out their function well without being seen."

View On Amazon

4. GutterStuff Foam Gutter Protection – Best Gutter Guards for Metal Roof

GutterBrush Simple Gutter Guard | for Standard 5 Gutters

If you think that all the gutter guards are supposed to be made of steel or aluminum – that is not true. GutterStuff is a brand that offers guards that are made of sponge. When you think about it, it is easy to assume that such gutter guards are extremely simple to install but not that durable after all. You are right if you say that. However, the price that the gutter guards come at and the 5-year warranty ensures that it is a mild disadvantage when compared to the advantages on offer. The fact is that the sponge material that is used for the creation of those gutter guards is not only very porous but also UV-rays resistant and fire retardant. Besides, no matter the gutters you use, you can always modify the foam to suit it.

Installation details

To install these guards, there are not so many tools or skills that you need to possess. Besides, if you check the video below, then you will become a real pro at the foam guards installation.

Expert Rating
Longevity
4.7 / 5
Value for Money
4.7 / 5
Easy to Install
4.6 / 5
Result
4.7
Pros and Cons
The material keeps mosquitos out
Goat guards are very economical and affordable
5-year-warranty
Filters the tiniest debris out
Foam gutter guard is less durable than a steel one
Heavy storms may rain over the gutters

Best Features

  • Effortless installation
  • Superb suitability to all shapes of gutters
  • UV-ray resistance of the material
Joseph Kirby
Joseph Kirby
Ask Question

"If you are looking for the gutter guards that can be easily installed without the need to hire a professional, the GutterStuff is the brand to give a try to. the price is surprisingly low. Still, in case you are ready to change your gutter guards in 5 years, that is a mild disadvantage."

View On Amazon

5. THE GUTTERBRUSH – Best Gutter Leaf Guard

GutterBrush Simple Gutter Guard | for Standard 5 Gutters

Some homeowners may be interested in something that is both easy to install on their own as well as practical. That is when GutterBrush comes in irreplaceable. The fact is that it is precisely what it sounds like – it is a brush made of steel and polypropylene that is placed inside your gutters to keep it safe from being clogged by leaves and other debris. One of the main advantages of these gutter guards is that they are multifunctional too, you can not only avoid gutter clogging when using them but also clean the gutters while taking the brushes out to clean them too. It is advised to clean gutter brushes at least once or twice a year.

Installation details

GutterBrush is extremely simple when it comes to modifications and installation. You can see the process in detail if you follow the video below:

Deleted:

Expert Rating
Durability
4.5 / 5
Value for Money
4.3 / 5
Easy to Install
4.8 / 5
Result
4.5
Pros and Cons
Adaptable to simple modifications
Withstands severe weather conditions
Double UV-rays bristle protection
Ensures the unobstructed flow of water
The steel core is susceptible to rust over time
Requires occasional cleaning
Tiny particles may go through

Best Features

  • Keeps the leaves and other debris out
  • Super simple to install and clean
  • Extremely durable and light
Expert Recommendations
Joseph Kirby
Joseph Kirby
Ask Question

"Those of you who are looking for gutter guards that are not only useful and practical but also simple to install should consider GutterBrush as a possible and quality way out. You are indeed going to need to clean the brushes and even the gutters from time to time. Still, you are going to save enough on the purchase and installation, not to mention the fact that the gutter guards are no worse compared to all the more expensive versions available online."

View On Amazon

Buyer’s Guide

Fall is one of those seasons that show you the most when suitable gutter guards are missing from your gutters. However, it is never enough to judge only by the reviews that you find online when you decide to purchase and install those practical gutter guards, there are some other particular and essential features too, and we are going to point all of them out in this buyer’s guide.

Size matters

Size matters

To begin with, it needs to be stated that there are some universal gutter guards as well as gutters. However, you need to beSize of Gutter Guard 100% sure that the size of your gutters will coincide with the guards you wish to install. That is why the first thing that you should do before you order your guards is to check the gutters’ size.

Main types of gutter guards

Main types of gutter guards

Gutter Guard TypeIt would be a lot simpler if all the guards were of the same size and type, but they’re not. That is why it is essential that you not only distinguish between all of them but also choose the model that suits your needs most. There are four main types to pick from:

  • Screen gutter guards. This gutter guard type is the most requested one on the market. First of all, the price for this guard type is more than affordable. Secondly, it filters the leaves and other debris, apart from tiny particles thoroughly. Thirdly, it is simple to install, and it also fits many types of gutter systems.

  • Solid gutter guards. Another quite popular gutter guard type would be solid guards. However, it needs to be mentioned that such a guard type is especially great for the industrial property since the design can withstand large pieces of debris falling on top. The downside of this gutter guard type is its complicated installation.

  • Insert the gutter type. This one of the easiest to install on your own gutter guard type. As the name suggests – all you need to do is to insert the guards into the gutters, as simple as that. There two subcategories of insert gutter guards – brushes and foams. Every user chooses the subcategory that suits the needs best. However, foam gutter guards are less durable than brushes, but they are also cheaper at the same time.

  • Micro-mesh gutter guards. If you are aiming at keeping the tiniest particles of debris out of your gutters, then a micro-mesh type is the one to consider. Such guards are super durable, light, and practical. They may turn out to be a little challenging to install. However, there is nothing you wouldn’t manage to succeed with if you follow proper instruction. Since this is a premium type of gutter guards, the price may turn out to be not that affordable for most house owners.

Installation methods

Installation methods

Just like with any other item installation, there are two routes to take – either install it on your own or ask a professional to do Gutter Guard Installationit. Of course, installing on your own may cost you less if nothing at all, if you do it right and calling a technician to do it for you will cost you a little extra.
Also, you need to know that the guards can be attached to the top of the gutters, or they can be installed under the shingles. It is the latter method that you need to worry about since if you do it wrong you may forget about your roof warranty, if you possess one, you may disrupt the shingles so that the water gets under and the roof starts leaking. That is why you need to consider all the pros and cons when opting for under the shingle guard installation.

Hardware required for Installation

Hardware required for installation

Install HardwareIt goes without saying that if you are having a professional install your guards, there is rarely any installation hardware that you should have at hand. Although, some gutter guards come without screw added to the pack so that you may need to purchase them separately. In case you decide to install the gutters on your own, a measuring tape, power drill, screws, box or wire cutter, and a ladder should help you succeed with the task.

Gutter maintenance guide

Gutter maintenance guide

  • The fact is that keeping your gutters clean is a lot simpler than you think. All that you need to do is to clean them at least Gutter Guard Maintenancetwice a year to keep them well-functioning. If you can take the guards out – take them out and clean them
  • If not, scrape away all the leaves and debris off the guards
  • Use a high-pressure water nozzle to wash away all the remaining debris in the gutters and on the guards
  • Check the drainpipes in case of clogging. You can use either the water hose or the plumber’s snake to achieve that.
  • Done!
Check the Run-length

Check the Run-length

Lenght of Gutter GuardIf you have been looking through the available gutter guards on the market, you may have noticed that they come in different sizes and lengths. It is advised to measure the length of your gutters first to figure out the length as well as the number of guard pieces that you are going to need. Of course, you can try to cut some unnecessary pieces off. However, that is not the most practical approach unless we are talking about foam guards.

FAQ
Are gutter guards worth the cost?
Joseph Kirby
It may seem like a significant investment since if we take a house that comes with a 200-feet gutter length, it may cost you up to $2000 to install the guards over all of them. However, if your gutters get clogged and begin to malfunction, it may lead to foundation damage, basement flooding, driveway flooding, mosquitoes nesting, etc., and trying to fix all those issues should they arise will cost you a lot more.
What are the best leaf guards for gutters?
Joseph Kirby
The main idea of all types of gutter guards is to ensure that neither leaves nor debris gets into the gutter. However, solid gutter guards and also micro-mesh ones are considered to be the best to deal with the issue.
Do gutter guards cause problems?
Joseph Kirby
The main reason why gutter guards were founded was to avoid problems like clogged gutters and drainpipes. However, it would be fair to point out a single downside that the guards may come with. In the vast majority of cases, gutter guards do not deal with heavy storms.
Do you need to clean gutters with gutter guards?
Joseph Kirby
One of the most misleading assumptions would be that gutter guards protect the gutters from everything. That is not true. Sometimes smallest debris can get in with water, and it starts to build up over time. That is why even guarded gutters should be cleaned at least ones a year.
What is the best gutter system?
Joseph Kirby
Every gutter system has its benefits and downsides. If you are looking for good quality for the fair price, then vinyl and aluminum guards are the ones on the list. However, stainless steel ones are said to be better, yet the price for those is higher too.
Is there a tool to clean gutters from the ground?
Joseph Kirby
If you are afraid of heights and you wonder if there is a way to clean your gutters remaining on the ground – there is, and it is named gutter iRobot. It is controlled by a remote and can be attached to a regular extension pole.

Conclusion

It is incredible how significant small details can be. At times, it may not even occur to you that your roof is leaking, or your basement is flooded just because your gutters are not protected accordingly. Such a simple addition to your gutter system as gutter guards can save you a lot of time and means spent on renovation. All you need to do is to find the type of guards that fit your needs most. There are types and budgets on the market that make it possible for anyone to update their gutters and make their homes safer. In our review, we presented to you all the necessary information that will help you find the best gutter guards for your lovely house with the least of efforts spent!

About the author

Joseph Kirby

Joseph Kirby

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment

Are gutter guards worth the cost?
It may seem like a significant investment since if we take a house that comes with a 200-feet gutter length, it may cost you up to $2000 to install the guards over all of them. However, if your gutters get clogged and begin to malfunction, it may lead to foundation damage, basement flooding, driveway flooding, mosquitoes nesting, etc., and trying to fix all those issues should they arise will cost you a lot more.
What are the best leaf guards for gutters?
The main idea of all types of gutter guards is to ensure that neither leaves nor debris gets into the gutter. However, solid gutter guards and also micro-mesh ones are considered to be the best to deal with the issue.
Do gutter guards cause problems?
The main reason why gutter guards were founded was to avoid problems like clogged gutters and drainpipes. However, it would be fair to point out a single downside that the guards may come with. In the vast majority of cases, gutter guards do not deal with heavy storms.
Do you need to clean gutters with gutter guards?
One of the most misleading assumptions would be that gutter guards protect the gutters from everything. That is not true. Sometimes smallest debris can get in with water, and it starts to build up over time. That is why even guarded gutters should be cleaned at least ones a year.
What is the best gutter system?
Every gutter system has its benefits and downsides. If you are looking for good quality for the fair price, then vinyl and aluminum guards are the ones on the list. However, stainless steel ones are said to be better, yet the price for those is higher too.
Is there a tool to clean gutters from the ground?
If you are afraid of heights and you wonder if there is a way to clean your gutters remaining on the ground – there is, and it is named gutter iRobot. It is controlled by a remote and can be attached to a regular extension pole.