How to Find the Best Toilet Seat: What you Need to Know

Finding the best toilet seat is important because it can make or break your bathroom experience. Today, we will find out which is the best!

Using your house’ toilet can be quite uneasy if your toilet seat is uncomfortable. After all, there are a dozen ways for a toilet seat to go wrong. It can be too old, too brittle, or too rough.


There are also toilet seats that were designed poorly. Thus, the “comfort“ in comfort room disappears.

Today, we will find out the best toilet seat that you can find on the market. There are many toilet seats with different features. Hence, we will tackle these and see which is the best for your preference!

Types of toilet seats​

Types of toilet seats

Before we jump into what you should consider when buying a toilet seat, you must be aware first of its types. Toilet seats usually have two common types. These are the round and elongated toilet seat.

As you might notice, these two types also tell the size that you’re getting. In fact, you can easily distinguish the two because the elongated seat is the bigger one. On the other hand, round toilet seats are the smaller version.

When it comes to exact measurements, round toilet seats measure just around 16 inches in diameter.

Meanwhile, the elongated toilet seat measures at 18 inches or higher. It should be noted that bigger is not necessarily better when it comes to toilet seats.

Both of these types have different measurements, but both are designed to give comfort to any person.

The difference between the two will depend more on which has more useful features for you. For example, more people find the elongated toilet seat to be easier and more comfortable.

But if you’re a homeowner with love for space-saving, a round toilet seat will suit you better. Remember, this all depends with your toilet bowl. If you have a pre-existing toilet bowl, then you can’t do much when it comes to changing your toilet seat.

Plastic vs. Wood​

Plastic vs. Wood

Another subtype category when it comes to toilet seats is the material used. Usually, the two most common ones out there are wood and plastic. Wood is the all-time favorite by many westerners because of it gives added warmth.

Although wood has been the staple of a good toilet seat, this doesn’t mean that plastic ones can’t make a case for being better.

You can still find great toilet seats that are made out of plastic. However, if you’re looking for one, just be sure to get a seat made from high-quality plastic.

One useful feature of wooden toilet seats is that they’re sturdier than plastic. Again, there are durable plastic toilet seats out there, but wooden seats will guarantee more of a fool-proof purchase.

Since they’re made out of wood, these toilet seats can take in more weight, thus preventing any cracks. So if you’re looking to play it safe, a wooden toilet seat will be a good option. Just remember that these seats are more expensive than the plastic ones.

What Else is There to Consider?​



The aesthetics of your toilet seat might be just a secondary concern after durability, but it still matters. Particularly, the toilet seat is one of the first things that people would see in your bathroom.

If you’re someone who has a lot of guests, having a toilet seat that’s visually appealing would be great. Remember, it doesn’t have to be a seat that’s made out of gold. Often, you just need to find a toilet seat that will suit the design of your bathroom.

If your bathroom has black linings, for example, try to look for a toilet seat with a touch of black to it!



Before, toilet seats are more commonly known as just a lid and an added layer for your toilet bowl. Nowadays, technology has caught up with your average toilet seat as well.

There are many innovations when it comes to toilet seats, with a lot of them coming from Japan.

As of now, there are toilet seats that are fully automated when it comes to their opening and closing mechanism. Also, you have seats that have a heater on it. Although wooden seats can offer you natural warmth, these seats are more advanced.

So if you’re a person who’s always having trouble with a harsh climate, this could be for you. Or maybe you’re someone who just wants a post-modern feel to his toilet bowl? A high-tech toilet seat sounds appealing indeed!​

Size and Installation​

Size and Installation

​Another feature that you should take a look into is the installation of the toilet seat. Toilet seats should be convenient to install. You’ll know it’s easy when you can do it by yourself.

Thus, try to avoid toilet seats that have complicated hinges. Not only could these be harder to install, but it can also break if handled wrongly. A good old fashioned hinge for your toilet seat will work just fine.

When installing your toilet seat, be sure that you have to correct size. This is why it’s important to know if you should buy the elongated or round seat.

Moreover, be sure to check the bolts that come with the seat. Sturdy and undamaged bolts are another thing that you should check before buying.

Our Top 5 Picks​

1. Raised Toilet Seat by Vive – Portable Elevated Riser with Padded Handles



Check Price & Review on Amazon

Vive’s Raised Toilet Seat boasts of its versatility as it fits on most standard toilet seat sizes (16.5 inches) and even elongated toilet seats (18.5 inches). That’s even with its added height.

What’s even better is that it claims to have no need for any tools during installation. It is also very easy to clean up with just one swipe.

But most importantly, it has padded handles for support and a lifetime warranty in case you need to replace yours with a newer one.


  • It is ideal for older people who need support. 
  • The handles are very elderly-people-friendly, and its added height makes sitting down or standing up easier for people with knee or leg problems. 
  • It is easily detachable or attachable. 
  • This makes it perfect for traveling due to its portability. 
  • It is very durable and offers excellent fitting. 
  • It does not wobble when you sit on it, and it can also handle up to 250lbs of weight.


  • The width size of the handles was not mentioned. 
  • This might pose a problem for bigger people because they might not fit in. 
  • The hole might be a bit small especially for big adult men. 
  • The seat might not be ideal for people with back or hip issues.

2. Mayfair 48SLOWA 000/848SLOWA 000 Slow-Close Molded Wood Toilet Seat


Check Price & Review on Amazon

The Mayfair 48SLOWA Slow Close Molded Wood Toilet Seat is available in three colors: Bone, White and Biscuit/Linen. It claims to fit perfectly on all toilet bowls made or manufactured in the U.S. and Canada. 

Similar to Vive’s Raised Toilet Seat, it also boasts of its easy to install and easy to clean feature. Mayfair’s 48SLOWA is made from durable molded wood with a high-gloss finish which is chip and scratch resistant.

It eliminates any slamming sound as well when you close it due to its Whisper-Close feature.


  • The materials and processes used to make Mayfair’s toilet seats are environment-friendly.
  • The toilet seat is flat.
  • Compared to toilet seats that are curved, this might cause less pain when you sit down on it or use it for extended periods of time. 
  • It does not wobble even when you abruptly sit on it.


  • The weight limit was not clarified. 
  • With too much weight, you might encounter cracks or damages. 
  • When you remove stains or dirt with cleaners or stain removers, the coating might come off. 
  • The plastic hinges might not be as sturdy especially when under more pressure or weight.

3. KOHLER K-4647-0 Stonewood Molded-Wood


Check Price & Review on Amazon

On the other hand, the Kohler K-4647-0 Stonewood elongated toilet seat features plastic hinges that are color-matched and is made primarily of compression-molded wood. It is designed to fit in either one or two piece toilets.

Similar to Mayfair’s, it is also available in three colors: Almond, White, and Biscuit. The toilet seat comes with screw and bolts for installation. But most importantly, it comes with a one-year limited warranty from the manufacturer.


  • It comes with screws and bolts. 
  • This makes installation much easier. 
  • The design is versatile. 
  • It can look good on almost any toilet. 
  • It does not wobble or move around.


  • The limited warranty might not be helpful if the particular part you want to be repaired/replaced is not covered.
  • It might not handle heavy weight because of its structure and toilet seat spacers.
  • You might find the screws not long enough. 
  • This might cause damage and might force you to buy new separate screws.

4. Bemis 500EC000 Molded Wood Round Toilet Seat With Easy Clean and Change Hinge


Check Price & Review on Amazon

The Bemis 500EC000 is also a molded wood toilet seat. However, it is rounded. It features an easy clean and easy change hinge. Even when you have to replace the hinges, the bolts do not have to be unlocked from the toilet.

Similar to the toilet seats listed above, it also claims to be easily installed and chip/scratch resistant. However, it comes in 10 colors to choose from depending on the color of your toilet itself.


  • It is aesthetically nice without sacrificing comfort. 
  • It is very easy to install. 
  • The materials used to make the toilet seat are of high quality.


  • Like most toilet seats, it also has limitations on its weight capacity. 
  • It does not come with an installation instruction guide. 
  • Cleaning it with powerful stain removers might leave discolorations on the wood.

5. Bath Royale Premium Round Toilet Seat with Cover, White


Check Price & Review on Amazon

Finally, the Bath Royale Premium Round Toilet Seat now comes with an option to either buy the elongated or rounded model.

It also claims versatility to fit on almost all toilet brands. It is made out of polypropylene plastic that is easier to clean and is stain resistant. 

Bath Royale’s Premium Toilet Seat comes with four SureFoot Bumpers to help evenly distribute weight and avoid damages.

Similar to Mayfair’s, it is also designed to eliminate any slamming wound with its soft-close feature. But most importantly, it is tested to withstand up to 400lbs of weight.


  • So far it has the highest weight capacity among all the reviewed products.
  • Can withstand up to 400lbs of weight
  • It is easy to install and easy to clean because of its materials. 
  • Comes with a quick release mechanism.
  • It makes opening and closing the lid much easier without the slam.


  • The lid might not be as durable if weight or pressure is applied to it.
  • If you have a bigger toilet, you might have trouble with the fitting. 
  • Cleaning materials for this particular toilet seat are very limited.

Our Verdict

The toilet seat should not just be sturdy and durable; it must also fit perfectly on your toilet. That is what minimizes damages or wobbliness. Although all the products are as equally good, we found one product that can support heavy weight or pressure.

The Bath Royale’s Premium Toilet Seat had very minimal issues in withstanding too much weight or pressure except for the lid.

Like other products listed above, it also has a soft-close feature and is very easy to install or clean. It offers comfort and aesthetic without compromising durability.

If you do not mind the limited cleaning materials you can use to clean it with, Bath Royale’s Premium Toilet Seat Might be a right choice for you.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: